I still remember the exact night this argument started in my group chat. Someone dropped a screenshot of PewDiePie’s old “100 Million Subscribers” trophy and asked, “wait, isn’t MrBeast bigger now?” What followed was twenty minutes of people pulling up different apps, getting different numbers, and nobody agreeing on anything.
That’s when I realized most people checking this comparison are looking at outdated screenshots, YouTube’s rounded-off display numbers, or random “top 10 YouTubers” lists that haven’t been updated since 2023. So I actually sat down, pulled live tracking data from a few different sources, and cross-checked it properly. Here’s what’s really going on.
The short answer
MrBeast has way more subscribers than PewDiePie right now. It’s not close.
MrBeast’s channel sits above 500 million subscribers, while PewDiePie is sitting around 110-111 million. That’s roughly a 4x to 5x gap. Ten years ago, saying that sentence out loud would have gotten you laughed out of a YouTube forum.
How I actually checked this (and why it’s trickier than it looks)
If you go straight to YouTube and look at a channel page, the subscriber count is rounded. MrBeast’s page might show “500M” and PewDiePie’s might show “111M.” That’s fine for a quick glance, but it’s not precise, and it definitely doesn’t tell you the growth trend.
Here’s the method I used, and you can copy it if you want an accurate answer instead of a guess:
Step 1: Skip the YouTube homepage number. It’s rounded and updates slowly.
Step 2: Use a live subscriber counter tool. Sites like Social Blade, vidIQ, and Livecounts pull numbers straight from YouTube’s API and refresh them constantly, sometimes every few seconds. I’ve used all three over the years for tracking my own Facebook pages and a few YouTube side projects, and Social Blade in particular is the one most creators check obsessively (a little too obsessively, honestly).
Step 3: Check the growth rate, not just the raw total. This is the part people skip. A channel can have more subscribers today but be shrinking, while a smaller channel is climbing fast. Numbers alone don’t tell the full story.
Step 4: Compare video output and posting frequency. This explains a lot of the gap, which I’ll get into below.
Why MrBeast pulled so far ahead
I used to think subscriber counts were mostly about “who’s been around longer.” That assumption turned out to be completely wrong, and it’s a mistake I see people make constantly in these comparisons.
PewDiePie has been on YouTube since 2010. MrBeast’s channel technically started around 2012. On paper, PewDiePie had a multi-year head start, built the platform’s first massive Let’s Play audience, and was the most-subscribed channel on all of YouTube for years. If subscriber growth were just about tenure, he’d still be way out front.
But here’s what actually happened: MrBeast built a content machine, not just a channel. Big-budget challenge videos, giveaways, philanthropic projects like tree-planting and ocean cleanup campaigns, and eventually entire competition shows with hundreds of participants. Each video is essentially event-level content, and that pulls in huge waves of new subscribers every single upload.
PewDiePie, meanwhile, scaled back years ago. He’s openly talked about being semi-retired from the daily grind of YouTube, uploading far less frequently and focusing on projects he personally cares about rather than chasing growth. His channel currently posts a fraction of the videos MrBeast puts out, and it shows in the numbers.
Neither approach is “wrong.” One is a guy who decided fame wasn’t worth burning himself out over. The other built what’s basically a media company around a YouTube channel. But if you’re purely measuring subscriber count, only one of those strategies produces exponential growth.
The moment the gap actually opened up
If you want a specific marker, MrBeast passed PewDiePie for the very first time in November 2022. Before that, PewDiePie had held the “most-subscribed individual creator” title for years, and it was genuinely a big deal in the online creator world when the numbers flipped.
What surprised me researching this is how PewDiePie reacted. In an earlier Q&A, he was asked directly whether he thought MrBeast would eventually pass him, and he said flat out that it was inevitable and that he actually hoped it would happen. No bitterness, no rivalry drama. That’s honestly more mature than half the comment sections arguing about it today.
Since that overtaking moment, the gap has only widened. MrBeast went on to hit 300 million, then 400 million, and became the first individual creator to cross the 500 million mark. PewDiePie’s growth, by comparison, has mostly flattened out.
Common mistakes people make comparing these two
Mistake 1: Comparing “total channel subscribers” to “individual videos.” MrBeast also runs side channels like MrBeast Gaming and MrBeast 2, plus Feastables and other ventures. If you’re doing a fair comparison, stick to the main channel numbers for both creators, otherwise you’re not comparing apples to apples.
Mistake 2: Trusting a screenshot without a date. I’ve seen “MrBeast vs PewDiePie” comparison images floating around that are years old, still showing numbers in the 300 million and 100 million range like it’s some kind of close race. It isn’t anymore, and hasn’t been for a while.
Mistake 3: Assuming subscribers equal relevance. PewDiePie still has one of the more engaged audiences on the platform relative to his upload frequency, and he’s genuinely respected as the guy who helped define what a YouTuber even is. Subscriber count is just one metric, not a scoreboard for cultural impact.
Mistake 4: Ignoring engagement rate. This one actually surprised me. When I checked engagement numbers side by side, PewDiePie’s audience engagement per video is notably strong for his upload pace, even though his total subscriber growth has slowed way down. MrBeast’s channel is obviously much bigger in raw numbers, but engagement percentage isn’t the same thing as subscriber count, and mixing the two up is an easy way to misread the data.
If you’re tracking this yourself
For anyone who wants to keep an eye on this comparison going forward instead of relying on outdated blog posts (including this one, eventually), here’s what actually works:
- Bookmark a live counter site like Social Blade or Livecounts and check the “compare” feature, which lets you put two channels side by side in real time.
- Look at monthly gained subscribers, not just the total. A channel gaining zero new subscribers in 30 days tells a very different story than the lifetime total suggests.
- Check upload frequency alongside subscriber count. It’s almost always the biggest driver of growth or stagnation.
Where things stand
MrBeast is, without much argument, the most-subscribed individual creator on YouTube, and it’s not particularly close anymore. PewDiePie built the foundation that made a career like MrBeast’s even possible, then deliberately chose to step back from the growth chase. Both outcomes make sense once you understand what each of them was actually trying to build.
If you check back on this in six months, don’t be surprised if the exact numbers have shifted. That’s the nature of live platforms. But the underlying gap between the two channels isn’t closing anytime soon.












